The Human Condition
Moderator: yoloswegmaster
- tenia
- Ask Me About My Bassoon
- Joined: Wed Apr 29, 2009 11:13 am
Re: The Human Condition
I had indeed exactly the same issue with the Taviani box and had to pass on reviewing them. It's only the more unfortunate since the highest ranked review on Google research is the partially laughable one from Socialist Review.
- Ribs
- Joined: Fri Jun 13, 2014 1:14 pm
Re: The Human Condition
I think it's a little unfair, though; thinking back, Fassbinder didn't get covered anywhere either, but whenever Criterion or MoC put out a big box of any kind (though they tend not to get as big as Arrow's) there's almost always comprehensive coverage from every reviewing site. Does a title need to be as big a deal as the Rivette set to get attention?
(I recognize BD reviewing isn't anyone's day job and ten hours of film is a lot to get through, let alone ten films as in the Fassbinder set)
(I recognize BD reviewing isn't anyone's day job and ten hours of film is a lot to get through, let alone ten films as in the Fassbinder set)
- domino harvey
- Dot Com Dom
- Joined: Wed Jan 11, 2006 2:42 pm
Re: The Human Condition
If I got paid the same for reviewing an 85 minute Kino Lorber Blu-Ray as a 10+ hour box set, why would I ever volunteer for the worse assignment?
- tenia
- Ask Me About My Bassoon
- Joined: Wed Apr 29, 2009 11:13 am
Re: The Human Condition
I'm not sure. I think, with Rivette, it might have to do with timing. I think the Rivette set was released at a time (Jan' 16) where there wasn't so many titles to review at once.Ribs wrote:Does a title need to be as big a deal as the Rivette set to get attention?
In the worst cases, I used to review only some movies within a set, but it felt so frustrating having to cherry pick that I chose to either do it all or not at all. Otherwise, you always end up with both a feeling of unfinished business and readers endlessly asking "When are you going to publish reviews for the other movies in the set ?" I also sometimes ended up writings very superficial reviews which, while relatively comprehensive, weren't in-depth enough to my tastes compared to what I can usually provide. It's a lose-lose in the end.
And yes, it usually relates to very heavy boxsets. You'll have exceptions (I don't find Human Condition or the Taviani set to be huge set like, say, a Fassbinder one) but on the other end, Battles without Honor was reviewed, for instance. The Outlaw VIP Gangster too, despite being 6 movies.
I don't think many of the reviewers are paid at all. I know it's not the case on Retro HD, and it's also not the case for DVD Classik and many other French websites (or is it just a French thing ?). I'm just happy being in touch with the labels somehow, getting early access to the BDs and trying to provide readers reliable info on whether or not the release is worthy of their money.domino harvey wrote:If I got paid the same for reviewing an 85 minute Kino Lorber Blu-Ray as a 10+ hour box set, why would I ever volunteer for the worse assignment?
Last edited by tenia on Sat Sep 17, 2016 10:37 am, edited 2 times in total.
- cdnchris
- Site Admin
- Joined: Tue Nov 02, 2004 2:45 pm
- Location: Washington
- Contact:
Re: The Human Condition
I just got the discs a few days ago, so that's my defense (finally got through everything lastnight).
- GaryC
- Joined: Fri Mar 28, 2008 3:56 pm
- Location: Aldershot, Hampshire, UK
Re: The Human Condition
I did cover the Taviani box (which I bought), albeit briefly, in my review column for Black Static, which is a print magazine. As the magazine is horror/dark fantasy-based, the review concentrated on Kaos, but I did refer to and list the extras for the other two films.MichaelB wrote:There seems to have been a similar attitude towards the Taviani box - none of the usual suspects has reviewed it to date, and the only substantial review that covers the discs as well as the films was in Sight & Sound a couple of issues ago. But that takes about thirteen hours to get through the whole thing (not counting reading time for the hefty accompanying book), and most of these people are unpaid, so...
But the fact is that my workload has increased this year so I can't take on many large boxsets as all my reviewing and also fiction-writing has to fit round my day job. And one of the box sets I did take on (take a guess which one) frankly exhausted me so I had to take a break for a while.
Last edited by GaryC on Sat Sep 17, 2016 11:58 am, edited 1 time in total.
- GaryC
- Joined: Fri Mar 28, 2008 3:56 pm
- Location: Aldershot, Hampshire, UK
Re: The Human Condition
The Digital Fix has covered 4/7 of the Fassbinder discs, all except Fear Eats the Soul by me. The remaining three disc reviews will be done, but have been delayed for various reasons, some of which are mentioned in my post above.Ribs wrote:I think it's a little unfair, though; thinking back, Fassbinder didn't get covered anywhere either, but whenever Criterion or MoC put out a big box of any kind (though they tend not to get as big as Arrow's) there's almost always comprehensive coverage from every reviewing site. Does a title need to be as big a deal as the Rivette set to get attention?
(I recognize BD reviewing isn't anyone's day job and ten hours of film is a lot to get through, let alone ten films as in the Fassbinder set)
-
- Joined: Sat May 10, 2008 1:10 pm
Re: The Human Condition
HG Lewis?GaryC wrote: And one of the box sets I did take on (take a guess which one) frankly exhausted me so I had to take a break for a while.
- tenia
- Ask Me About My Bassoon
- Joined: Wed Apr 29, 2009 11:13 am
Re: The Human Condition
It was the Alan Clarke one.David M. wrote:HG Lewis?GaryC wrote: And one of the box sets I did take on (take a guess which one) frankly exhausted me so I had to take a break for a while.
- Ribs
- Joined: Fri Jun 13, 2014 1:14 pm
Re: The Human Condition
Given the review here couldn't specify, here's the transfer info from the booklet (limited though it may be):
The Human Condition is presented in its original aspect ratio of 2.35:1. The HD transfer was completed on a Spirit Datacine using new prints struck from the original 35mm negatives.
Parts One and Two (parts one to four in the Japanese release version) were originally presented in mono, and the soundtracks were remastered from a 35mm optical soundtrack print. Part three (parts five and six in the Japanese release version) was the first Japanese film to be presented in stereo in its original release, and the audio was remastered from the original magnetic stems.
The restored HD master was suppled for this release by Shochiku Co, Ltd.
The Human Condition is presented in its original aspect ratio of 2.35:1. The HD transfer was completed on a Spirit Datacine using new prints struck from the original 35mm negatives.
Parts One and Two (parts one to four in the Japanese release version) were originally presented in mono, and the soundtracks were remastered from a 35mm optical soundtrack print. Part three (parts five and six in the Japanese release version) was the first Japanese film to be presented in stereo in its original release, and the audio was remastered from the original magnetic stems.
The restored HD master was suppled for this release by Shochiku Co, Ltd.
- MichaelB
- Joined: Fri Aug 11, 2006 6:20 pm
- Location: Worthing
- Contact:
Re: The Human Condition
I should probably mention (given the use of the word "unfortunately" in Chris's review) that it was an entirely deliberate decision to go with the version that had onscreen Japanese "side-titles".
We were offered the option to go without, but I noted that Criterion's DVD favoured on-screen textual accompaniment too, and I suspect for very similar reasons - it allows the monolingual English-speaking viewer to clearly differentiate when non-Japanese languages are being spoken (I note that Eureka took a similar approach with The Burmese Harp), and because the text is down the side rather than along the bottom it didn't clash with the English subtitles.
Hence the decision, which I still firmly believe to have been the right one.
We were offered the option to go without, but I noted that Criterion's DVD favoured on-screen textual accompaniment too, and I suspect for very similar reasons - it allows the monolingual English-speaking viewer to clearly differentiate when non-Japanese languages are being spoken (I note that Eureka took a similar approach with The Burmese Harp), and because the text is down the side rather than along the bottom it didn't clash with the English subtitles.
Hence the decision, which I still firmly believe to have been the right one.
-
- Joined: Tue Apr 14, 2009 4:29 am
Re: The Human Condition
I agree. It's also useful for Japanese speakers who don't want the English subtitles on whilst they watch it in Japanese.
- Michael Kerpan
- Spelling Bee Champeen
- Joined: Wed Nov 03, 2004 1:20 pm
- Location: New England
- Contact:
Re: The Human Condition
Other than color coding and side-titling -- what other options are there for indicating/hinting exactly what foreign language is being spoken during the course of a multi-lingual film?
- zedz
- Joined: Sun Nov 07, 2004 7:24 pm
Re: The Human Condition
There's also the inclusion of stage directions like (in Mandarin) being added to the subs, but that can get incredibly unwieldy if it happens with any regularity.Michael Kerpan wrote:Other than color coding and side-titling -- what other options are there for indicating/hinting exactly what foreign language is being spoken during the course of a multi-lingual film?
- theflirtydozen
- Joined: Fri Dec 05, 2014 4:21 pm
Re: The Human Condition
When I saw Les innocentes from this year I believe they used a different color text for the few Russian lines. Of course, you run into problems re:color-blindness then.Michael Kerpan wrote:Other than color coding and side-titling -- what other options are there for indicating/hinting exactly what foreign language is being spoken during the course of a multi-lingual film?
- tenia
- Ask Me About My Bassoon
- Joined: Wed Apr 29, 2009 11:13 am
Re: The Human Condition
Yes, SDH subs can use normalized color-coding in some countries (that's the case in France) : yellow for off-screen people talking, red for sound effects, pink for music-related stuff, blue for voice-over and internal thoughts, and finally green for foreign language.theflirtydozen wrote:When I saw Les innocentes from this year I believe they used a different color text for the few Russian lines. Of course, you run into problems re:color-blindness then.Michael Kerpan wrote:Other than color coding and side-titling -- what other options are there for indicating/hinting exactly what foreign language is being spoken during the course of a multi-lingual film?
- MichaelB
- Joined: Fri Aug 11, 2006 6:20 pm
- Location: Worthing
- Contact:
Re: The Human Condition
...and of course going down that route makes it rather tougher at the authoring end than simply using a source with non-Japanese dialogue already highlighted. And given the running time, this is an even more important consideration!
- colinr0380
- Joined: Mon Nov 08, 2004 4:30 pm
- Location: Chapel-en-le-Frith, Derbyshire, UK
Re: The Human Condition
This is all from the perspective of someone who has not seen the films as yet, but I always think its best to leave subtitles in films where the original audience would have needed them in the first place. It's not just good for differentiating languages for those of us at an even further remove but it could also be argued that its part of the original aesthetic of the film. Although granted I doubt we are talking Night Watch and Day Watch levels of flashily integrated CGI subtitles here! But still I think its good to preserve those aspects (and original font choices, and screen placement, etc) as much as possible as they can tell you as much about a filmmaker's intentions as the film itself sometimes! Especially for the realisation that they really want the audience to understand the content of the dialogue in a different language, and that there is a difference there versus say avoiding subtitles to place the audience more in the shoes of a character who might not understand what is being spoken at all - both equally valid approaches but with different aims.
I know that bumps up against what aesthetically looks pretty and overlaying another layer of English language subtitles onto the image too, so there must be difficulties and considerations for how cluttered the screen is going to become, but I always find it interesting to see 'original' (i.e. intended for all versions of the film at the time, not just added for specific territories later) subtitles and intertitles. Its part of why I got so annoyed with MGM in the early DVD era when they scrubbed out theatrically added subtitles and intertitles and replaced them with electronic (and presumably easily interchangable for other local language) ones! Sure that probably practically made sense, but you don't get the same effect from say Silence of the Lambs' 'official looking' location titles when they are just generic ones and don't look typed. The best films usually try to at least make the subtitles and intertitles that they feel necessary to include look interesting and tied to the aesthetics of their world.
I know I bring this up a lot, but the anime Macross: Do You Remember Love? is a good, if extreme, example of multiple things going on at once in its climactic 'love song saves the universe' muscial number. That's a film with a big subtext of division and misunderstandings between humans and aliens, and is part of the reason why 'protoculture' in the form of a song cuts through all of that and speaks across racial divisions. In that final sequence you have the Japanese dialogue, the musical number going off in the background (with its Karaoke-style singaong subs!) and at least in my VHS version all the alien dialogue is subtitled in Japanese too! The attached video has kind of cleaned it up a bit, but in doing so loses a little of the power of the moment when the aliens speak directly to the humans in their own language to say they will defend them.
I know that bumps up against what aesthetically looks pretty and overlaying another layer of English language subtitles onto the image too, so there must be difficulties and considerations for how cluttered the screen is going to become, but I always find it interesting to see 'original' (i.e. intended for all versions of the film at the time, not just added for specific territories later) subtitles and intertitles. Its part of why I got so annoyed with MGM in the early DVD era when they scrubbed out theatrically added subtitles and intertitles and replaced them with electronic (and presumably easily interchangable for other local language) ones! Sure that probably practically made sense, but you don't get the same effect from say Silence of the Lambs' 'official looking' location titles when they are just generic ones and don't look typed. The best films usually try to at least make the subtitles and intertitles that they feel necessary to include look interesting and tied to the aesthetics of their world.
I know I bring this up a lot, but the anime Macross: Do You Remember Love? is a good, if extreme, example of multiple things going on at once in its climactic 'love song saves the universe' muscial number. That's a film with a big subtext of division and misunderstandings between humans and aliens, and is part of the reason why 'protoculture' in the form of a song cuts through all of that and speaks across racial divisions. In that final sequence you have the Japanese dialogue, the musical number going off in the background (with its Karaoke-style singaong subs!) and at least in my VHS version all the alien dialogue is subtitled in Japanese too! The attached video has kind of cleaned it up a bit, but in doing so loses a little of the power of the moment when the aliens speak directly to the humans in their own language to say they will defend them.
Last edited by colinr0380 on Fri Sep 23, 2016 6:54 am, edited 1 time in total.
- MichaelB
- Joined: Fri Aug 11, 2006 6:20 pm
- Location: Worthing
- Contact:
Re: The Human Condition
I wasn't too concerned about clutter, as the Japanese side-titles are on the extreme right of a Scope-framed image, so are easy enough to tune out. Had they been along the bottom, I would almost certainly have favoured the "clean" masters.
- cdnchris
- Site Admin
- Joined: Tue Nov 02, 2004 2:45 pm
- Location: Washington
- Contact:
Re: The Human Condition
If there's any consolation there was, at one point, a statement that somehow got lost when reworking it where I said it wasn't a big deal (just noticeable) and I assumed it was because these were the best materials available, though it appears that wasn't actually the case. I had originally came to that conclusion because Criterion's DVD did the exact same thing.MichaelB wrote:given the use of the word "unfortunately" in Chris's review
The reality is I really don't care that they are there so "unfortunately" was more than likely not warranted.
- PianoMan88
- Joined: Sun Dec 25, 2016 4:50 am
- Location: Toronto, ON
Re: The Human Condition
Has the Blu-ray offering from Arrow gone on sale at any point? As far as I can see it is going for £45 on Amazon UK and £50 on Arrows website at the moment.
Any advice if one should wait for a sale (what's the likelihood of that?) or get it now. I wish Arrow would let us know how the sales of their Academy boxsets are going, especially the Limited Editions such as this.
Thank you for any advice/pointers on how to go about getting this.
Any advice if one should wait for a sale (what's the likelihood of that?) or get it now. I wish Arrow would let us know how the sales of their Academy boxsets are going, especially the Limited Editions such as this.
Thank you for any advice/pointers on how to go about getting this.
- swo17
- Bloodthirsty Butcher
- Joined: Tue Apr 15, 2008 10:25 am
- Location: SLC, UT
Re: The Human Condition
It was 50% sold out in October. Many of their limited editions like this completely run out before ever having been offered on sale, so if you want to make sure you don't miss out you should probably get it sooner rather than later. If you're willing to take a chance that it will still be here in March (when we're due for another sale), you might buy it then so that you can get double points on your order. When you do, order it separately from any sale items, and redeem any points that you might have saved up by then to optimize their value.
- Ribs
- Joined: Fri Jun 13, 2014 1:14 pm
Re: The Human Condition
Counterpoint: Every single Academy box is still in print, except for Boro and Koyaanisqatsi+Powaqatsi.
- Lowry_Sam
- Joined: Mon Jul 05, 2010 3:35 pm
- Location: San Francisco, CA
Re: The Human Condition
I'm still waiting (and I'm sure a few others are too) for Criterion to release their upgrade so we can see whether there will be anything added before plunking down $ for this one.
- Drucker
- Your Future our Drucker
- Joined: Wed May 18, 2011 9:37 am
Re: The Human Condition
I would say there's no certainty Criterion upgrades this.