I haven't bought this yet but might as well eventually, since I'm not holding my breath for a Criterion Blu, and they'd probably just make it from their HD master with that colour grading. So the MoC is my likely destination anyway, regardless of whether the combing is significantly visible or not.swo17 wrote:For all its flaws, the Blu-ray corrected the color scheme from the DVD, and had higher resolution.
But out of curiosity, how noticeable is the combing when one is not using a projector?
And thanks, Nick, for sharing this. And sorry that I'm here to thank you so belatedly. I haven't seen The Insect Woman, but Pigs & Battleships and especially Profound Desires of the Gods are indeed superb Blus. Not to mention the rest of the MoC titles I have.peerpee wrote:It's the worst MoC Blu-ray transfer, and as time goes on, it's looking more and more like a mistake to have bothered. It was made from a very early HD telecine that had a ton of problems. A lot of work was done in the encode to try and make the best of it, and this solved a lot of problems, but not all of them unfortunately.
Criterion have an HD master without any of these issues, but with a slightly different colour grading.
Don't let it put you off any of the other Imamura Blu-rays, all of which are quite stunning (or indeed any of the other MoC Blu-rays!)